Add Your Review
Thanks for visiting Reilly's Pub. We'd love to have your feedback!
Our Latest Reviews
We brought new friends 2 weeks ago for a fish fry, the service was fabulous and the baby pike was the best fish fry I think I have ever had! My other favorite meal on the menu is the corned beef it is absolutely amazing! Thank you to all the staff for always giving us great service and great food! Our favorite place up here!!
Went vegitarian 5 months ago. This Mediterranean wrap was great! And the fries put it over the top!!
Great tasting pizza. Huge and plenty leftover for the next day. We don't go any where else for pizza.
Love the atmosphere, the side lounge and by FAR the BEST Rueben I've had.
The wings (traditional and boneless) are great. They have Legend Larry's sauces which are award-winning from Sheboygan. Also, it comes with homemade potato chips or choice.
Whoa!! Best ever! The food at Reilly's pub is consistently excellent, every time.
This is our favorite Rueben in all the world. And the Reuben rolls are unbelievably excellent. The tomato soup is so so good. We're just so fortunate to have this gem on Big Green Lake!!
When in Green Lake one must go to Reilly's and try the Green Lake Burger. It is phenomenal...loved the avocado, onion, tomato and dressing on the bun. Best Burger in the state and something you absolutely don't want to miss! I ordered curbside and before I had a chance to call to let someone know I was there, I had someone at my car door with my food. Superb service! Thanks Reilly's!
I tried the perch and Kay had the cod - cajun style. Both were absolutley outstanding! Heather made us awesome old fashioneds while we waited. Can't wait for next Friday!
Friday night perch & cod tnight outside on the patio. Couldn't ask for anything more❤️ food was exceptional, waitstaff friendly and attentive. Beautiful weather.
This burger had so much flavor, loved it! Every time we've eaten at Reilly's Pub it's been amazing and the team is all wonderful. Fun atmosphere as well. HIGHLY RECOMMEND!
our meals were very good! I had coconut shrimp & boyfriend had the perch dinner. We will definitely be back. We enjoyed the outdoor seating area and our server, Piper, did an excellent job. Can't wait to come back soon :)
The chicken tenders are very good. The raspberry habanaro sauce was excellent. Spicy and sweet.
Super good Loved the taste!
Very good taste, chicken was juicy. Staff was very friendly
Love Reilly's! We've been coming here for years and they've always got nice food and drinks and a beautiful view!
I took my family from AZ for a bite to eat. Everyone was very pleased with their meal. The service was great. Way to go Reilly's!
Always order these! Delicious and a tradition!
The BEST Reuben I've even had. I order it every time in stop in. My spouse always has the Reilly's Rolls.
Reilly's, without a doubt, has the best menu on Green Lake. There are so many great things but the Blackbird Berry wrap is my go-to. It's fresh and full of flavor, plus the fries are bomb!
Better than homemade! Be sure to add bacon and the pretzel stick is the ultimate side!
Amazing cheese from the best bar/restaurant in the area!
This burger is my favorite & it's name makes it that much better! The pretzel bun was a must. Best burger I've had and a fan favorite for my family. Love Reilly's Pub!
Ordered the Mac and cheese for takeout. Piping hot! Very cheesy, good flavor. Enough for two meals for me. Will be ordering again!
This place is worth the drive from any location! I come about every weekend. The staff is always so welcoming and the whole atmosphere is so welcoming. Feels like you're eating at home with the excitement of eating out. The chicken strip basket seems simple, yet the chicken is always wonderfully cooked and clearly good quality meat. I have tried a few other things such as the chicken sandwiches, which are also to die for. I have never had a bad experience here and will continue to come on a regular basis for as long as I can.
My favorite "go to" at Reillys. Never a bad meal at this great place:)
Come on, these are the best. Along with the fried Ruben and cheese curds. Food is better then ever at Riley's.
Almond & Cranberry Chicken Salad
Best Chicken salad around!!! It's not too heavy on the mayo, and I love the spinach wrap you can get it in... I get it every time we are in town!
One of the best burgers I have ever had. First time there, will definitely go back
Reilly's pub has outstanding food! We frequently dine in and on the boat. Drive up, pick up and head back out on the boat! Service is always fast and with a smile! What an amazing gem on Big Green Lake!
Absolutely LOVED the Rueben mac n cheese! Bring it back please!!!
Everything I have at Rielly's has been very good. But I love the Reilly Roll, the great taste of a Rueben and very filling! I can't wait until you have your special desserts back! They are awesome! Staff members are friendly and attentive!
Fish tacos are awesome. I keep ordering them but plan to try another menu next time I stop. Menu has nice selection.
Not quite NYC deli but Reilly good for the Midwest.
Spectacular Reuben. Never had a bad meal at Reilly's Pub.
Reilly's Rueben Sandwich is slow cooked and amazingly tender. This sandwich is very delicious. Reilly's rueben is the best tasting anywhere and BIGGEST one I've ever had. It's two meals in one!
Avocado Strawberry Basil
This makes the list of the top ten best salads I've ever had in my life. A unique flavor combination plus the freshest ingredients around. I could have eaten two right in a row - and you know, next time I think I will. Truly heavenly and exquisite.
One of the best appetizers in the area! Great for 2 people to split but very filling. I like to split the order with my husband and get one of the fresh salads on the menu as my meal!
The food is awesome, we have ordered several times, and never been unhappy. We love Reilly's. Service is great. Very accommodating. Keep up the great work!!!!
Best Friday night fish in the state!!! Also amazing old fashions.
PAST DRAWING WINNERS
Costa Mesa, CA
Carol, Stroud's BBQ
Daytona Beach Shores, FL
Jo-El, Mick's All American
Mount Joy, PA
Bronson, Los Dos Potrillos
Elish, Crump's Landing
Carlson, Papi Grande's Mexican
Sommer, Little Calf Creamery
Thousand Oaks, CA
Theresa, Woody's Crab House
North East, MD
Maria, The Rustik Fork
Marsha, Stefano's Restaurant
Alma, Karai Ramen Bistro
Courtney, Axe & Arrow
Andy, Backwoods Brewing Co.
Amanda, Home Restaurant
Los Angeles, CA
Jennifer, Mark's City Grill
Rebecca, Frank Gourmet
Donna, Dino's Sports Bar
Cape Cod, MA
Karen, This Little Pig
Alicia, Plant Based Pizzeria